I have to pick one of these two CAN YOU HELP

Discussion in 'General Discussions' started by burton6369, Jun 13, 2018.

  1. burton6369

    burton6369 New Member

    Weare needing to replace a 22-year-old geothermal unit in a home We have been in now for a year.
    So We only are replacing the unit itself and have come down to two companies but their products are not the same. That's where I need help.
    One bid is for a Geocomfort YT048 install price(install price 1$11.500)
    The other unit is a climatemaster Install price (TXV-22 Tranquility System - $ 13,900.00)
    Do you know the better machine I have tried looking up but I cant tell which is the better model
  2. docjenser

    docjenser Well-Known Member Industry Professional Forum Leader

    what matters is who is the better installer, not the machine.
  3. ChrisJ

    ChrisJ Active Member Forum Leader

    Ask to see other installs or speak to other clients.

    Has the house had insulation upgrades? might be able to down size to 036 model and be more efficient.

    Closed loop? new circulation pump? Some new units come with pumps inside.

    I have the Climatemaster w/communicating thermostat and like that I can see info like entering and leaving water temps.

    DeSuperheater option? 2 hot water tank set up, instead of 1 tank.
  4. nc73

    nc73 Member Forum Leader

    Climatemaster. Nice markup for a day or 2 worth of work. I'm assuming direct replacement of course, no major mods or design changes.

Share This Page